CPS sets new standard for witness care at Birmingham shootings trial
18/03/2005
Crown Prosecution Service care for witnesses in this murder trial has set precedents for future cases where those giving evidence fear for their lives, said West Midlands Chief Crown Prosecutor David Blundell.
Mr Blundell said: "Bringing this case to court could hardly have been more challenging. The shooting was a horrific act of violence and because of the close links between many of those at the party, witnesses were reluctant to approach police for fear of reprisals - let alone attend court."
He paid tribute to the courage of prosecution witnesses, including Cheryl Shaw and Sophie Ellis, who were seriously injured in the shooting that claimed the lives of Charlene Ellis and Letisha Shakespeare.
Mr Blundell said: "Giving evidence in any case is not an easy thing to do. In this particular case, the prosecution witnesses showed great courage in being prepared to come to court and see justice done."
"From the start the CPS and West Midlands Police knew that a future court case would demand extreme witness care and we drew up a witness strategy in the weeks following the shooting."
The prosecution had to convince the court to grant a range of measures, at the trial venue in Leicester, including:
- Total witness anonymity and pseudonyms for four witnesses. The court was cleared and a police security strategy put in place to bring them to court.
- Rarely used voice distortion. The CPS hired a specialist sound firm to slightly lower the pitch of witnesses' voices while the dock was specially sealed so the witnesses' real voice could not be heard by the defendants and a time delay of several seconds put in place to avoid accidental identification.
- West Midlands CPS paid for three plasma TV screens to be installed in another courtroom to allow the public and press to hear anonymous witnesses' evidence and see judge and counsel.
The size of the case was reflected in the amount of material prosecutor Timothy Raggatt QC had to use: 700 exhibits copied over 2500 pages and thousands of pages of mobile phone data. Expert evidence in mobile phone use was crucial in the case to place the times and places phones were used - often for calls lasting only seconds.
Mr Blundell said: "I'm convinced we made the right decision. No resource was spared in the investigation and prosecution of this case. CPS West Midlands worked as a team with West Midlands Police from the early days following the shooting in January 2003 and we would like to thank them for their tireless work."
Finally, our thoughts rest with the parents, other family members and friends of Charlene and Letisha.
Notes to Editors
Media enquiries to CPS National Press Office on 020 7710 6088.
